 Chemistry Help Forum 1:1 Solution from Solutions of Two Different Ratios
 User Name Save? Password

 Advanced Chemistry Forum Organic chemistry, analytical chemistry, inorganic chemistry, physical chemistry, and biological chemistry questions go here.

 Thread Tools Display Modes Jan 27th 2015, 04:03 PM #1 ProdofChem Junior Member   Join Date: Jan 2015 Posts: 1 1:1 Solution from Solutions of Two Different Ratios I searched to see if I could find a similar problem posted to no avail, so apologies if this is a repeat. It's been a few years since my chemistry degree, and anyway I don't think I had ever seen this problem before now. I have two solutions with two compounds of interest, each, call the solutions 1 and 2; the compounds within them A and B. Solution 1 will be used in toto, it's volume V1, and concentrations of both solutions are known. The question is, what volume of solution 2, V2, is required to create a final solution in which [B][A]= (1:1 solution, not to be confused with i:f notation of dilutions). This seems like a straightforward question, but my mind creates several ways to attack it and I'd like to bounce this off some peers as it actually matters whether or not I do it correctly. Option I: [A final]/[B final] = 1 = V1[A1]/[B1] + V2[A2]/[B2] V2 = [B2]/[A2] - V1[A1]/[B1] This doesn't look right and I don't trust it. I'm guessing that's because 1 = is not a valid argument once I incorporate volume into the equation. I think it should though, because volume*concentration should give you content, or mass, and the ratio of the compounds' masses must be 1. Actually I get why this doesn't work -- it is stating that if volume increases, the ration of A to B will change, which is untrue. In reality it should be V1[A1]/V1[B1], which is just A/B, which means that this will not help me figure out the volume I need of the second solution. Option II: Really just a reworking of Option I... [A final] = [B final] V1[A1] + V2[A2] = V1[B1] + V2[B2] V2 = V1 ([A1]-[B1])/([B2]-[A2]) This is what I ended up going with, but today I am rethinking myself. Option III: Graph the damn thing. Y1 is the total mass of compound A per volume (X) of added solution 2. Y2 is the same for compound B. Where they intersect, they will have the same total mass (or # particles, whichever value m or M is handy) of each compound at the given volume of added solution 2. Concentrations of solution 2 will serve as slope coefficients; concentrations of solution 1 will serve as y-intercepts, respectively. Y1 = [A1] + [A2]X Y2 = [B1] + [B2]X Y1 = Y2 [A1] + [A2]X = [B1] + [B2]X X = ([A1]-[B1])/([A2]-[B2]) Hmm that looks kinda familiar... Okay, so which (if any) are right? What am I missing?  Tags 1:1, equal concentration, equal concentrations, solution, solutions Thread Tools Show Printable Version Email this Page Display Modes Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode 